From Buddha to Jesus: An Insider’s View of Buddhism & Christianity
From Buddha to Jesus: An Insider’s View of Buddhism & Christianity by Steve Cioccolanti.
The compelling story of one man’s involvement with Buddhism - the religion of choice for increasing numbers of people in the traditionally ‘Christian’ Western world. Discovery the radical differences between Buddhism and Christianity.
This book and website are devoted to exploring the Buddhist heart, mindset and culture from a native Christian perspective. Having grown up in a household of Buddhists, Catholics, Methodists, and Muslims, all of whom Steve loved, he chose to become a Christian. Steve has lived with and ministered to Buddhists in many nations. The content of the book and website is intended for those who are interested to understand Buddhism the way it is lived among millions of Buddhists whose faith may be imperfect and often syncretic.

moo
on July 19th, 2009
Ven. Shravasti Dhammika, REAL ‘Buddhism ’s
Insider’, Has Reviewed this book once
please, I beg you, Christians, or Anybody, who interested in this book, read his review here :
http://www.buddhistchannel.tv/index.php?id=10,7797,0,0,1,0
I, Myself, A Thai Buddhist, like Steve, I was born and grew up in the same environment like him, I can tell anyone that Steve is a BAD one, He did not, I repeat, understand his former religion at all. for him, Buddhism is just traditional, born with it, they-told-me-so, full of superstition religion (very true to ‘typical’ Thai Buddhist like Steve).
He is, just like Christians in the West, get tired of he faith that he was, because of his ignorance, blindly followed for too long.
You cant hardly call someone like Steve as ‘Insider of Buddhism’. by Calling him such is like calling Bin Laden an ‘Insider of Islam’. It’s Insulting.
But as the Buddha said in Kalama Sutra,
Don’t believe something based on just what you ‘ve Read or somebody told you about or because it’s in your tradition or because your parents told you so, not until you’ve tried, tested, and be effected positively or negatively by yourself.
So I encourage anybody to read his book if you have a chance, and After that, Remember, test it by yourself, look up, search for more information, asks other, find out what other REAL gurus in Buddhism says what in the same issues that Steve point out in his book.
rogermorris
on July 19th, 2009
Hello Moo. Many thanks for posting. Have you read the book? The author is aware of the review that you speak of and has a detailed three-part response on his blog: http://buddhabook.org/bookblog/?p=64.
I am only part way through this book, but so far the author (who’s mother is Buddhist) has been very generous in his discussion about Buddha and Buddhists. He speaks of the insight of Buddha in many matters and the similarities between his teachings and the teachings of Jesus.
He has reserved his criticism so far (and very mild, polite at that) at Westerners who “cherry-pick” Buddhist philosophy and practices, thinking that that somehow makes them a Buddhist. He talks about how popular Western Buddhism does not really represent traditional Buddhism. The critic you cite is a Western convert to Buddhism.
Like Christianity, I gather Buddhism is very diverse and variable in belief and practice, depending on which region it is practiced.
I encourage you to read the book yourself and make your own judgements.
Bhikkhu aggacitto
on September 9th, 2009
Hi Everybody!
I am a Buddhist monk who has also written a review about the book “From Buddha To Jesus” by Mr.Steve Cioccolanti. I believe that if one were to read my review and compare it to the book and then NOT understand what a lying Christian propagandist Mr. Steve Cioccolanti really is, such a persons capacity for self deception would have to be truly unfreaking believeable!
I would suggest one go to:
http://www.scribd.com/doc/19107203/
or
dhammaprotector.blogspot.com/
The three part ‘review’ that is spoken of here regarding the review that the Venerable Shravasti
wrote of this book is much less a review of the
review itself and much more of a picking apart of other material that the Venerable Sir once wrote elsewhere.
Why has Mr.Steve Cioccolanti NOT written a review of my review? This is why! He knows that he would not have much more to say other than…
Well O.K.! Bhikkhu aggacitto is correct!
I AM a Christian propagandist lying liar!
I have nothing against Christianity as a religion strickly speaking,for those who who choose to believe it, I just dont believe that someone who is truly walking a spiritual path should find it nessassary to LIE about someone elses spiritual path. Fair enough?
I wish you ALL the very best of ALL things spiritual!
Bhikkhu aggacitto
Bhikkhu aggacitto
on September 9th, 2009
Hi Everybody!
I am a Buddhist monk who has also written a review about the book “From Buddha To Jesus” by Mr.Steve Cioccolanti. I believe that if one were to read my review and compare it to the book and then NOT understand what a lying Christian propagandist Mr. Steve Cioccolanti really is, such a persons capacity for self deception would have to be truly unfreaking believeable!
I would suggest one go to:
http://www.scribd.com/doc/19107203/
or
http://dhammaprotector.blogspot.com/
The three part ‘review’ that is spoken of here regarding the review that the Venerable Shravasti
wrote of this book is much less a review of the
review itself and much more of a picking apart of other material that the Venerable Sir once wrote elsewhere.
Why has Mr.Steve Cioccolanti NOT written a review of my review? This is why! He knows that he would not have much more to say other than…
Well O.K.! Bhikkhu aggacitto is correct!
I AM a Christian propagandist lying liar!
I have nothing against Christianity as a religion strickly speaking,for those who who choose to believe it, I just dont believe that someone who is truly walking a spiritual path should find it nessassary to LIE about someone elses spiritual path. Fair enough?
I wish you ALL the very best of ALL things spiritual!
Bhikkhu aggacitto
Bhikkhu aggacitto
on September 9th, 2009
Hi again Everyone!
Sorry about the double posting!
I realized that I had not put the http:// in front of
one of the web site addresses that I gave!
For some I thought that it might make a difference.
Have a blessed day!
Bhikkhu aggacitto
rogermorris
on September 9th, 2009
Thank you Bhikkhu for your perspective.
I must point out that I have not and do not rely on one person’s perspective about other faiths - thus I have taken Mr Cioccolanti’s opinions in context.
Bhikkhu aggacitto
on September 10th, 2009
Hi again everybody!
I just took a look at a response from the Venerable Shravasti Dhammika regarding the response of Mr.Cioccolanti to his review of the book “From Buddha To Jesus” that is mentioned above. I found it some what humorous and wanted to share it with all concerned.
http://sdhammika.blogspot.com/2009/04/long-list.html
Have a great day!
Bhikkhu aggacitto
Anonymous
on September 27th, 2009
Well I for one am completely ataken by the comments of aggacitto. Unless he is the norm for Right Speech, statements like “what a lying Christian propagandist Mr. Steve Cioccolanti really is, such a persons capacity for self deception would have to be truly unfreaking believeable” are not all all becoming a Buddhist Monk. Sounds to me like this particular monk is the epitome of control by ILL-WILL.
In all seriousness, I felt embarrassed reading his post to this particular article. I am a practicing Buddhist, coming from a Christian upbringing, and can’t believe this kind of hatred coming from one of the holy ones who has dedicated their life to freedom from GREED, ILL-WILL and DELUSION … or should I lable him as one of the Un-Holy ones. There were those who had followed Devadata, afterall.
If it were at all possible for someone else to appologize for this kind of hatred, I would, I could, and I do.
I’ve read his SCRIBD pages and they are more propogation of hatred and anger as I have seen from any practitioner of Buddhism, in either Mahayana or Theravada schools.
Bhikkhu aggacitto
on September 29th, 2009
Dear “Anonymous” and everyone else!
Hatred?Anger? No, this is simply TRUTH telling.The review that I have written is about truth telling.The “norm” for right speach is truth telling.There were also the words”I believe” that well qualified the statement that you chose to be “ataken” by. Anything else was as well apparently my opinion which I believe I am well entitled to.There are always those who seem to believe that a “good ” Buddhist (or anyone walking a spiritual path in general) is someone who will bend over and lick up whatever lying/abuse that they have to offer, and if they don’t that it should be used as some sort of mark against the credibility of their spiritual conviction. I of course would beg to differ. This Christian pastor has written lie after lie after lie after lie after lie about the Buddha dhamma ( teaching) slanders the Buddha, AND the monastic sangha again and again, and someone like you becomes offended because you don’t like the way that I’ve talked about it! You know what? To Bad!
It is ironic that you say the things in your post simply because you don’t believe that I should say the things that I say, and that those comments themselves seem truly full of such anger!
For those who would like to take a look at the review in question the address is :http://www.scribd.com/doc/19107203
While you’re at it check out the interesting articles at the blog: http://dhammaprotector.blogspot.com!
I SINCERELY WISH YOU, MR. CIOCCOLANTI AND EVERYONE THE VERY BEST OF ALL THINGS SPIRITUAL!
Bhikkhu aggacitto
Bhikkhu aggacitto
on September 29th, 2009
Hi Again !
Once AGAIN,sorry about the double posting,I was trying to correct something as regards to how this was getting posted. Never mind!
Thanks Everyone!
Bhikkhu aggacitto
J. C
on November 13th, 2009
Hi Everyone,
I’m a practising Buddhist but I do learn from the Bible.
All I can say about this book is that I think the author has very superficial understanding of the religion. I think it’s quite silly of him to go around converting Buddhist to Christians because it is such a waste of time. Considering the fact that there are so many countries living below the poverty line, I feel that Buddhist are the least of his concern. Just look at Mother Theresa. She didn’t go around converting people. All she did was to help people regardless of all religions. I think the author is very sly, as he got a number of reviews that were quite positive. However, if u look at it carefully, the reviewers are all Christians… Of course, they do not know what’s going on. If a Buddhist said that it is a good book about Buddha, then it will be a true review. Unfortunately it is not.. Sometimes, I think that because of all these “definition” it separates people and that is the cause of all the problems in the world. I have realized long ago that one has to be objective, learn from ALL religions, pick out the best and apply it to one’s own life. After reading the scriptures and text from both religion, I think that Buddha is more defined. He will define what he says. But he’ll always say that one must practise because words cannot describe the experience that he has experienced. I think the Jesus’s teaching are more cryptic and more open to interpretation. So one needs to let go of his ego in order to receive his teachings. I could go on for days but I think that’s all for now.
I suggest to all not to take his book so literally. I think there’s a very good book (although it’s not suitable for beginners) titled: In Buddha’s Words edited by Bhikkhu Bodhi. I’ve read this book and I think it’s great.
Bhikkhu aggacitto
on June 8th, 2010
Hi everybody!
Heres the new link to my book review of Steve Cioccolanti’s book “From Buddha To Jesus”:
http://dhammaprotector.blogspot.com/2009/09/namo-tassa-bhagavato-arahato_19.html
Have a great day!
Bhikkhu aggacitto